ARK Asks the SEC to Drop Two Unlaunched CoinDesk 20 ETFs
ARK Investment Management asked the US Securities and Exchange Commission on 20 November to let it withdraw the registration statements for two crypto index funds that never traded. The letters cover the ARK CoinDesk 20 Crypto ETF and the ARK CoinDesk 20 ex-Bitcoin Crypto ETF, both registered on 23 January. Neither registration became effective and no shares were issued or sold. The firm gave a single reason: it does not intend to proceed with the planned distribution. ARKB, the spot bitcoin fund it runs with 21Shares, is untouched.
Two letters, one filing date
The requests went in under Rule 477 of the Securities Act of 1933, the route an issuer takes to pull a registration it no longer plans to use. Crypto Briefing and Coindoo each read both letters and report two funds. The Crypto Times covered the standard fund alone and does not mention the ex-Bitcoin twin, which is a gap in coverage and not a conflicting claim. That outlet adds a point the others leave out: the filing is an application for consent, effective 20 November or the earliest practicable date after. Consent has not been reported as given.
Neither fund would have held a coin
Both were registered as commodity pools under the 1933 Act, not as investment companies under the 1940 Act, with shares to list on NYSE Arca. The standard fund's registration describes long positions in CoinDesk 20 Index futures traded on ICE Futures U.S., with the rest of the assets in cash and Treasury securities to cover margin. Coindoo and The Crypto Times both take that from the S-1. Crypto Briefing's account names the commodity-pool wrapper and the cash and government-securities collateral, and does not mention the futures at all. Read alone, that description would leave a reader thinking the funds held the index. Futures-based products are contested ground elsewhere, where six trading firms backed the CFTC on single-stock perpetual futures.
Taking bitcoin out meant selling it short
The CoinDesk 20 tracks the 20 largest crypto assets by market value and leaves out stablecoins and memecoins. Its factsheet caps the largest member at 30% and every other member at 20%, reset at each quarterly rebalance. Bitcoin is the asset pressing against the top cap. The second fund was meant to track that index with its bitcoin-related members stripped out, which the filing defines as bitcoin and Bitcoin Cash.
The route was subtraction. ARK planned to hold the full index through ICE futures, then sell CME bitcoin futures to cancel the bitcoin slice. With bitcoin near a 30% weight, a dollar of index futures carries only about 70 cents of exposure to everything else. A fund putting its whole value into the rest of the basket would need a long position larger than its own assets, plus a short big enough to neutralise the bitcoin inside it. The ex-Bitcoin registration left the ticker, the sponsor fee and the share of assets committed to futures blank, so the sizing is unrecorded.
The index futures at the centre of both designs were, in ARK's words, "new instruments without a significant trading history."
What the documents do not say
Because both funds were pulled together, the bitcoin hedge cannot be singled out as the reason. What the two designs shared was that ICE contract and the commodity-pool structure built around it. Four months before the January filings the Commission approved generic listing standards letting exchanges list spot-holding commodity trust shares, digital assets included, without a separate rule change each time. ARK's designs used futures anyway. Neither the registrations nor the withdrawal letters discuss that choice.
Nothing here measures demand. With no shares ever sold there are no flows, redemptions or volumes to read. One fewer candidate for large-cap crypto exposure beyond bitcoin sits in the pipeline. ARK withdrew post-effective amendments tied to its ARK Crypto Active ETF registration in March on the same stated ground, The Crypto Times reported. VanEck ended Gemini custody for its bitcoin, ether and SOL ETFs this month, a product that did launch. Whether the Commission has consented to these two withdrawals has not been reported.
Read also: Bitcoin ETFs Are Negative for 2026 and the Tallies Do Not Agree